Archive for: May 2011

Email insight: Engagement vs deliverability, how does one affect the other?

Recently I had a discussion with one of our deliverability experts about engagement vs deliverability. Rumors were that if subscriber engagement is low webmail providers like Hotmail, GMail and Yahoo would punish you by not letting the email get through to the inbox.

He responded by noting that deliverability with those providers has not been affected so far by (the lack of) engagement, but more by bounces, blacklisting, bad content and bad addresses overall. This is the classic set of deliverability affecting issues: put crap in, either list-wise or content-wise, and get crap out: it’s that simple.

However, if your content is up to par or better, and your lists are fine, then you should have nothing to worry about. Some online marketers are troubled by dropping (or in general bad) open rates, others care more about clickthrough or total campaign performance, regardless of what other metrics say.

Rory Carlyle notes over at his blog that all metrics count: and I agree with him, up to a point. Focusing on a single metric is useless in email marketing: measuring all metrics across the board will tell you so much more. From delivery rate to opens, to clickthroughs and actual sales, downloads or whatever you are trying to promote: seeing the big picture is worth gold.

This big picture will also help in explaining small parts of it: for instance if open rates are low but sales are high, how could you explain that? People didn’t see the content you reason, so why is your email offer selling so good? It’s simple, really: your subject line must have been so good that it said enough.

At the Fusion Marketing Experience in Brussels in March this was pointed out by Dela Quist of Alchemy Worx: he said that a retailer sent an email offer on a Thursday, and open rates were dreadful. However, sales were beyond expectations and everyone loved it. The reason was that the sales was clearly stated in the subject line, and that was all that anyone needed to know to rush to the store the next day. Sometimes email marketing can be that simple, and worrying about deliverability or bad metrics can be unnecessary or at the very least, prevented.

Getting back to the engagement vs deliverability part: deliverability is currently much more affected by the following facets of email marketing:

  • quality of content, or the lack thereof
  • sender and/or IP reputation
  • quality of list used, or the lack thereof

So if your content is fine, your reputation (or that of your email service provider) is fine and the list you are using is fine, you have nothing to worry about when it comes to deliverability: there are other things to tune in your email marketing campaigns. More on that later!

Email insight: crowded inboxes of the future

Over half a year ago I wrote a post on crowded inboxes in preparation for the holiday season. Now that we’re running up to the summer I’d like to take a look at how our inboxes will be evolving in the future.

More email, more spread

As email is the glue to social media, notifications of all networks you’re using will keep pouring in. Those networks will also be expanding their email communications to drive more traffic, as they will have a lot more shareholders in the (near) future. LinkedIn recently had their NYSE debut and saw their stock price rise no less than 171 percent. This also means the pressure is on to perform well and consistently well, now and in the future. Social media performance is driven by visits and activity, which is no different than with many other websites and platforms. Through notifications and network update emails the likes of Facebook and Twitter make sure people don’t forget to check in as often as possible. Actually posting or tweeting something is not even necessary: just watching a few ads (and hopefully clicking too) is sufficient.

This also means that the amount and timing of receiving emails in one’s inbox will be more diverse: not just concentrated on certain times of day or day of the week. This will come on top of other groups of email (a recap from last year’s crowded inboxes overview):

- invoices and purchase confirmations
- welcome campaign messages from subscriptions
- tickets for events, movies, trips and more
- media like presentations, personal movies, pictures
- earlier noted social media notifications
- software update notifications
- (internal) event and agenda notifications from your own agenda, company or group
- spam (sorry, it’s still part of email sadly)
- ‘regular’ private email

There is some good news about the worst type of email however: in recent months spam volume has dropped sharply according to Cisco Ironport spam monitoring, and it looks like it’s staying that way too:

In a year’s time a drop of nearly 90% volume (328.6 billion to 34.1 billion). Much spam is already caught way before your inbox but it is reassuring to know that it is a continuous trend towards a lot less spam. This will be countered however by companies depending on lots of (legal) email volume to spread their message, like Groupon: my girlfriend received no less than 30 emails in just a few days from them.

Be aware that when you signup for offers or newsletters and you cannot set a frequency, the sender is allowed to send you as much email as they want: even if this might be 10 or 20 times a week. Dela Quist notes this in an interview earlier this year on Socialemailmarketing.eu by J-P De Clerck when discussing email frequency. Chances are you will be receiving email from email marketers on different days, times and frequency than you’re used to, because they are pushed to get more ROI out of email marketing and one of the first things that will pop up is to boost frequency and tune timing to maximize results.

Email anywhere

The spread mentioned in the first subtitle in this post also has to do with people getting more mobile with their email. It’s not necessary to sit at a clunky desktop anymore, or even have a notebook with WiFi these days: just a smartphone or tablet with internet connection and you have your email with you, anytime anywhere. For both office and personal use this means receiving email will become a perpetual thing instead of focussed on specific times and days. Having a bunch of emails coming in on a Saturday or Sunday instead of during the Mo-Fri week will be normal instead of unique. People will be out and about and emailing you about anything and everything.

Cost

Which brings me to one of the final points: cost. Either way you put it, communication costs money. Whether it is the platform or service you are using that costs money, or the messages by itself: someone has to make money off it. In the case of email however, the cost is so low on all types of connections that it is the preferred way of communicating in terms of volume and/or distance. Text messages still cost quite a lot compared to what providers like Vodafone and T-mobile are paying for it. In recent times people here in The Netherlands have been flocking to replacement platforms, like Blackberry Ping, Whatsapp!, regular social media platforms and more.

The providers have been researching this using a disputed technology called DPI (Deep Packet Inspection) to check upon what services people are using. It turned out that 85% of KPN clients are using Whatsapp! which eats into the profits made off text services. Vodafone is already known for blocking VoIP because this means they will make less money selling classic talk minutes to their subscribers.

What does all of this have to do with email? It is one of the things that eat up nearly half of our time on mobile devices, according to a Mashable article from a year ago. We are using it an awful lot and I hope providers will not be blocking the email services on smartphones, or charging per sent / received email: it would severely affect Net neutrality. If they’re going to charge for data usage it’s fine, but not what people are using: that is none of the providers’ business actually. For the moment (and hopefully in the future too) email will stay one of the cheapest and most convenient means of communication, both on mobile platforms and otherwise. As you sign up for more and more services, more email notifications will head to your inbox to keep you up to date: where else would they send it?

In the end I believe email frequency will rise and people shall have to learn to manage it or bring that frequency down, to prevent it losing its effectiveness and appeal. After all, logging in to read your email and seeing 179 new emails over the past 2 days is no fun, is it?

Email news: mobile messaging, GMail ads, geolocations, zombie email addresses

According to a new research study by ReturnPath, email is on the move shifting no less than 16% of its usage to mobile. Have a look:

Email designs / webmail clients / browsers

New York Times: GMail to allow images, but no animation, in ads

Deliverability / (anti) spam / security / law

ReturnPath: How Inactive Addresses Hurt Deliverability plus 3 Tips on What to Do
iMediaConnection: Don’t spam me: Targeting tips for successful email marketing
Spamtips: DNSBL safety report
Wordtothewise: separating out zombie addresses (it would be nice)

Mobile

ReturnPath: Email on the Move: The Future of Mobile Messaging
TechCrunch: 14% Of Groupon/LivingSocial Subscribers Respond To Push Notifications

Other email marketing news and posts

ClickZ: New metrics that matter by Ryan Deutsch
ClickZ: Creating Effective – and Profitable – Birthday Emails by Jeanne Jennings
ReturnPath: It’s 2011, do you know where your email is being read? (report)
BenchmarkEmail: 6 types of content for your email
MediaPost: Dear [Email Marketer First Name], Hold Your Breath by Kara Trivunovic

Social media vs email vs …

Futurelabs: 72% of Companies Ignore the Influence of Email on Social Media

 

Also, follow Emailblog on Twitter for more daily email marketing bits and bytes.

 

Email winner: Threadless

Disclaimer: I love Threadless tshirts. But when it comes to email, I’m critical, even when it’s about Threadless. Nevertheless the below email caught my attention: mostly because it follows the KISS principle of simpleness and unclogged design. The design itself however is also lavishly done. Take a look:

The top has been cut off, but that includes the link to the online version, the add to safe sender list and a forward to a friend option. Winning points:

- social savvy: no less than 6 social platforms on which you can find Threadless to connect with.
- When it comes to shopping you just don’t go to the website, but get to decide if you want to shop guys or girly. Preemptive selection strike, nice.
- A link to the subscription center offers not just general settings but also let’s you choose between receiving it in German, Spanish or French.
- Taking a forward into account they provide a subscribe link for convenience as well.
- A heads up on summer sale too, great to warm the audience up for a shopping spree.

As one negative point you could say that this email is very image heavy: but on the other hand an email by Threadless deserves that: it gives it so much more atmosphere.

All in all a nice email by the Threadless team.

Email news: email design recs, subject line testing, Facebook Messages

After some vacation time we’re back. This time with the evolution of email, email being very much alive and subject line testing. Have a look:

Email designs / webmail clients / browsers

Retailemailblog: Email Design & Coding Recommendations: Executive Summary

Deliverability / (anti) spam / security / law

iMedia connection: Don’t spam me: Targeting tips for successful email marketing
DMA Email: How to test subject lines | The trouble with click-through rates | 10 most common delivery problems

Mobile

DMA Email: Social Media and Mobile Integration – Making Interactivity even more important

Other email marketing news and posts

Clickz: Money and Lists Sizes Aren’t Everything
Sailthru: Maximizing customer value (and not re-engagement campaigns!)
Mashable: The evolution of email

Social media vs email vs …

ExactTarget: Facebook Messages, the end of email? (report)
Social media forum: Social Media Monitoring: The Virtual Duck Blind
Social email marketing: Email Marketing: Where the sidewalk ends the relationship begins
DMA Email: Email, it’s alive!

In closing, it turns out The Netherlands is #1 in penetration for Twitter and LinkedIn (comScore results). Nice!

 

Also, follow Emailblog on Twitter for more daily email marketing bits and bytes.